Penultimate Thoughts on Against the Day
Tuesday, April 3rd, 2007I’m nearing the end of this monumental tome (20 pages left!) and I’m collecting my thoughts. Actually, truth be told, my thoughts were largely collected several hundred pages ago, which is not to the book’s credit. I’m a Pynchon fan, having read everything but Mason and Dixon over the last 15 years, and I eagerly anticipated this book. So, while I’m still blown away by the talent, I’m afraid that this is not his best work.
The maximalist prose is still there, and the classic TP themes are there: the paranoid interpretation, the galloping across history, the ludic sense of humor, the constant interplay of light and illumination, the hard left anti-corporate stance, all of which I love. But …. mmm, where do I start. First, frankly, the man needed an editor here: the book too often feels like an indulgence, an overflowing accretion of ideas. Of course Pynchon has never been the sculptor who produces a chiseled David, but here he’s the sculptor who just kept throwing more and more clay on the figure until it bloats past any point. Someone save this man!
What’s ironic to me too is that of all TP’s books, this is the most overflowing and yet oddly the most linear. For all the time travel talk and the sprawling across 3 decades of turn-of-the-century history, everything pretty much happens in order, it’s clear what year we are in at any given point in the book, and by-god things might even happen for a reason! Quite ironic given his continuing digs at the “Christian linear sense of time,” the toying with bilocation (etc) all the time, and whatnot. So for once his narrative structure is out of line (in it’s linearity) with his narrative topoi — which, when coupled with the book’s sheer unrelenting length, makes this reader end up saying: “Huh?”
One intriguing thing, though, about TP’s reluctant seduction by the muse of linear narrative is that he plays very successfully with some classic authorial voices. For example, he starts with the Chums of Chance narratives, which are straight out of Horatio Alger or other Boy’s Life serial chronicles (side note: why does he abandon the CoC? they were such a great sidebar commentary on the major lines of narrative!). Or again, I just finished reading the bit at the end of Part 4, where he dons the Chandlerian ethos for the hard-boiled detective in Southern California between the wars. Magnificent! It really is impressive how he can take such a classic voice and adopt it and make it his own.
I just got it! This is TP’s covers album! Hee hee. Almost.